Best Yankees Stocking Stuffers 2026
13 Yankees stocking stuffer picks — Tervis 24oz Defend with Straw, Yankees Mini Stein Ornament Set, Yankees Black Ultra Suede Luggage Tag, tokidoki Yankees Unicorno Enamel Pin.
Independently selected by NYC Sports Wire editors. Some links in this guide are affiliate links — if you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support our editorial coverage. Prices and availability accurate as of April 2026 and subject to change.
Yankees stocking stuffers anchor three ways. Tervis and WinCraft drinkware leads — Tervis Yankees 24oz Defend Classic Tumbler with Straw Lid ($24, the marquee), Tervis Yankees 24oz Tradition Classic Tumbler ($22), WinCraft Yankees Slim and 12oz Can Cooler 4-Pack Set ($22), WinCraft Yankees 16oz Icicle Silicone Pint Glass ($20). Ornaments and pins and magnets — Yankees Two-Pack 3-inch Mini Stein Ornament Set ($25), tokidoki Yankees Unicorno Enamel Pin ($25), Yankees 3-Pack Ornament Set ($25), WinCraft Yankees 5-Pack Key Ring and Fridge Magnet Set ($24), Lusso Yankees Olek Keychain Bottle Opener ($24). Travel tags and stein and pint glasses — Yankees Black Ultra Suede Luggage Tag ($25), Yankees Brown Ultra Suede Luggage Tag ($25), Yankees 16oz Pint Glass Two Pack ($25), Yankees Etched 16oz Vertical Rally Cry Pint Glass ($23). 13 picks from $20 to $34.
Independently selected by NYC Sports Wire editors. We may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site, at no extra cost to you.
Tervis + WinCraft Drinkware Stuffers
Four picks — Tervis 24oz Defend Tumbler with Straw, Tervis 24oz Tradition Tumbler, WinCraft Slim 12oz Can Cooler 4-Pack, WinCraft 16oz Icicle Silicone Pint at $20-$24.
Tervis New York Yankees Defend 24oz. Classic Tumbler With Straw Lid
Tervis New York Yankees Defend 24oz. Classic Tumbler With Straw Lid — Tervis 24oz Defend with Straw-line piece. Section top pick — Tervis 24oz Defend with Straw at $24.
See the Tumbler →
WinCraft New York Yankees 16oz. Icicle Silicone Pint Glass
WinCraft New York Yankees 16oz. Icicle Silicone Pint Glass — WinCraft 16oz Icicle Silicone Pint-line piece. WinCraft 16oz Icicle Silicone Pint at $20.
See the Glass →
Tervis New York Yankees 24oz. Tradition Classic Tumbler
Tervis New York Yankees 24oz. Tradition Classic Tumbler — Tervis 24oz Tradition-line piece. Tervis 24oz Tradition at $22.
See the Tumbler →
WinCraft New York Yankees Slim & 12oz. Can Cooler 4-Pack Set
WinCraft New York Yankees Slim & 12oz. Can Cooler 4-Pack Set — WinCraft Slim 12oz Can Cooler 4-Pack-line piece. WinCraft Slim 12oz Can Cooler 4-Pack at $22.
See the Cooler →Ornaments + Pins + Magnets
Five picks — Mini Stein Ornament Set, tokidoki Unicorno Pin, 3-Pack Ornament Set, WinCraft Key Ring + Magnet, Lusso Olek Bottle Opener at $24-$25.
New York Yankees Two-Pack 3" Mini Stein Ornament Set
New York Yankees Two-Pack 3" Mini Stein Ornament Set — Yankees Two-Pack Mini Stein Ornament Set-line piece. Section top pick — Yankees Two-Pack Mini Stein Ornament Set at $25.
See the Set →
WinCraft New York Yankees 5-Pack Key Ring and Fridge Magnet Set
WinCraft New York Yankees 5-Pack Key Ring and Fridge Magnet Set — WinCraft 5-Pack Key Ring + Fridge Magnet-line piece. WinCraft 5-Pack Key Ring + Fridge Magnet at $24.
See the Set →
tokidoki New York Yankees Unicorno Enamel Pin
tokidoki New York Yankees Unicorno Enamel Pin — tokidoki Yankees Unicorno Enamel Pin-line piece. tokidoki Yankees Unicorno Enamel Pin at $25.
See It →
New York Yankees 3-Pack Ornament Set
New York Yankees 3-Pack Ornament Set — Yankees 3-Pack Ornament Set-line piece. Yankees 3-Pack Ornament Set at $25.
See the Set →
Lusso New York Yankees Olek Keychain Bottle Opener
Lusso New York Yankees Olek Keychain Bottle Opener — Lusso Olek Keychain Bottle Opener-line piece. Lusso Olek Keychain Bottle Opener at $24.
See It →Travel Tags + Stein + Pint Glasses
Four picks — Black Ultra Suede Tag, Brown Ultra Suede Tag, 16oz Pint Glass Two Pack, Etched 16oz Vertical Rally Cry Pint at $23-$25.
Black New York Yankees Ultra Suede Luggage Tag
Black New York Yankees Ultra Suede Luggage Tag — Yankees Black Ultra Suede Luggage Tag-line piece. Section top pick — Yankees Black Ultra Suede Luggage Tag at $25.
See It →
New York Yankees Etched 16oz. Vertical Rally Cry Pint Glass
New York Yankees Etched 16oz. Vertical Rally Cry Pint Glass — Yankees Etched 16oz Vertical Rally Cry Pint-line piece. Yankees Etched 16oz Vertical Rally Cry Pint at $23.
See the Glass →
Brown New York Yankees Ultra Suede Luggage Tag
Brown New York Yankees Ultra Suede Luggage Tag — Yankees Brown Ultra Suede Luggage Tag-line piece. Yankees Brown Ultra Suede Luggage Tag at $25.
See It →
New York Yankees 16oz. Pint Glass Two Pack
New York Yankees 16oz. Pint Glass Two Pack — Yankees 16oz Pint Glass Two Pack-line piece. Yankees 16oz Pint Glass Two Pack at $25.
See the Glass →Common questions
Frequently asked
How did we organize Yankees Stocking Stuffers?
Three sections: Tervis + WinCraft drinkware stuffers (Tervis 24oz Defend with Straw, Tervis 24oz Tradition, WinCraft Slim 12oz Can Cooler 4-Pack, WinCraft 16oz Icicle Silicone Pint), ornaments + pins + magnets (Yankees Mini Stein Ornament Set, tokidoki Unicorno Enamel Pin, 3-Pack Ornament Set, WinCraft 5-Pack Key Ring + Fridge Magnet, Lusso Olek Keychain Bottle Opener), and travel tags + stein + pint glasses (Yankees Black Ultra Suede Luggage Tag, Brown Ultra Suede Luggage Tag, 16oz Pint Glass Two Pack, Etched 16oz Vertical Rally Cry Pint). 13 picks from $20 to $34.
Best Yankees stocking stuffer if I had to choose one?
For drinkware marquee: the Tervis Yankees 24oz Defend Classic Tumbler with Straw Lid at $24 (section hero). For ornament marquee: the Yankees Two-Pack Mini Stein Ornament Set at $25 (section 2 hero). For travel marquee: the Yankees Black Ultra Suede Luggage Tag at $25 (section 3 hero).
Tervis 24oz Defend with Straw vs Tervis 24oz Tradition Tumbler?
Two Tervis Yankees-branded 24oz tumbler picks at $22-$24. Tervis 24oz Defend Classic Tumbler with Straw Lid at $24 (section hero) features 24oz Defend-line tumbler with straw lid included. Tervis 24oz Tradition Classic Tumbler at $22 features 24oz Tradition-line classic tumbler. For straw lid: 24oz Defend with Straw. For classic tumbler: 24oz Tradition.
WinCraft Slim 12oz Can Cooler 4-Pack vs WinCraft 16oz Icicle Silicone Pint?
Two WinCraft Yankees-branded specialty drinkware picks at $20-$22. WinCraft Slim 12oz Can Cooler 4-Pack Set at $22 features 4-pack of slim 12oz can coolers. WinCraft 16oz Icicle Silicone Pint Glass at $20 features 16oz Icicle-line silicone pint glass. For can cooler 4-pack: Slim 12oz 4-Pack. For silicone pint: 16oz Icicle Silicone.
Yankees Mini Stein Ornament Set vs tokidoki Unicorno Enamel Pin vs 3-Pack Ornament Set?
Three Yankees-branded ornament/pin picks at $25 each. Yankees Two-Pack 3-inch Mini Stein Ornament Set at $25 (section 2 hero) features 2-pack of 3-inch mini-stein style ornaments. tokidoki Yankees Unicorno Enamel Pin at $25 features tokidoki Unicorno-style designer enamel pin in collaboration. Yankees 3-Pack Ornament Set at $25 features 3-piece Yankees ornament set.
WinCraft 5-Pack Key Ring + Fridge Magnet vs Lusso Olek Keychain Bottle Opener?
Two Yankees-branded keychain/magnet picks at $24 each. WinCraft 5-Pack Key Ring + Fridge Magnet Set at $24 features 5-pack combination of key rings and fridge magnets. Lusso Olek Keychain Bottle Opener at $24 features Olek-line keychain with built-in bottle opener function. For 5-pack keychain/magnet: WinCraft 5-Pack. For bottle opener keychain: Lusso Olek.
Yankees Black Ultra Suede Luggage Tag vs Brown Ultra Suede Luggage Tag?
Two Yankees-branded ultra-suede luggage tag colorway picks at $25 each. Yankees Black Ultra Suede Luggage Tag at $25 (section 3 hero) features Black ultra-suede travel luggage tag. Yankees Brown Ultra Suede Luggage Tag at $25 features Brown ultra-suede travel luggage tag. For Black colorway: Black Ultra Suede. For Brown colorway: Brown Ultra Suede.
Didnt find the right Yankees stocking stuffer? Browse the full Yankees collection on Fanatics for the complete catalog.
Shop the Full Yankees Collection →