Best Yankees Heirloom Memorabilia 2026
11 Yankees heirloom picks — Judge Embellished 30x40, Jeter 16th 150-Hit Inscription, Core Four Quad Replica Jersey, Judge Player-Worn 2025 Jordans.
Independently selected by NYC Sports Wire editors. Some links in this guide are affiliate links — if you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support our editorial coverage. Prices and availability accurate as of April 2026 and subject to change.
Yankees heirloom memorabilia anchors three ways at the premium-tier. Aaron Judge premium heirloom pieces lead — Aaron Judge Autographed Stretched 30-by-40-inch Embellished Photograph ($6,000, the marquee), Aaron Judge Autographed Player-Worn White Jordan Brand Shoes from the 2025 MLB Season ($3,000), Aaron Judge Autographed Fastest Player in MLB History to Reach 70 Home Runs Inscription ($2,500), Aaron Judge Autographed Framed 20-by-24-inch 62nd Home Run Collage with Game-Used Dirt Capsule ($2,000). Derek Jeter premium heirloom pieces — Derek Jeter Autographed 16th Consecutive 150-Hit Season Inscription ($3,300), Derek Jeter Autographed Career RBI 1000 Inscription ($3,000), Derek Jeter Autographed Game Model Black Bat with HOF 2020 Inscription ($2,400), Derek Jeter Autographed Gray Mitchell and Ness 1998 Authentic Jersey ($2,300). Core Four quad-signed memorabilia — Jeter, Pettitte, Posada and Rivera Autographed Replica Jersey ($3,000), Core Four Autographed 1996 World Series Memorabilia ($2,500), Andy Pettitte, Derek Jeter, Jorge Posada and Mariano Rivera Autographed Core Four Memorabilia ($2,500). 11 picks from $2000 to $6000.
Independently selected by NYC Sports Wire editors. We may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site, at no extra cost to you.
Aaron Judge Premium Heirloom Pieces
Four picks — Judge Embellished 30x40, Judge Player-Worn 2025 MLB Jordan Shoes, Judge Fastest 70 HR Inscription, Judge 62nd HR Framed Collage at $2,000-$6,000.
Aaron Judge New York Yankees Autographed Stretched 30" x 40" Embellished Canvas Giclee Print - Art by Cortney Wall - Limited Edition of 50
Aaron Judge New York Yankees Autographed Stretched 30" x 40" Embellished Photograph — Judge Embellished 30x40-line piece. Section top pick — Judge Embellished 30x40 at $6,000.
See It →
Aaron Judge New York Yankees Autographed Framed 20" x 24" 62nd Home Run Collage with a Capsule of Game-Used Dirt from 62nd Home Run Game - Limited Edition of 99
Aaron Judge New York Yankees Autographed Framed 20" x 24" 62nd Home Run Collage with a Capsule of Game-Used Dirt — Judge 62nd HR Framed Collage-line piece. Judge 62nd HR Framed Collage at $2,000.
See the Frame →
Aaron Judge New York Yankees Autographed Fastest Player in MLB History to Reach 70 Home Runs Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9 Ticket from May 26, 2018 with "Fastest to 70 HR" Inscription
Aaron Judge New York Yankees Autographed Fastest Player in MLB History to Reach 70 Home Runs Inscription — Judge Fastest 70 HR Inscription-line piece. Judge Fastest 70 HR Inscription at $2,500.
See It →
Aaron Judge New York Yankees Autographed Player-Worn White Jordan Shoes from the 2025 MLB Season - HH98517174-75
Aaron Judge New York Yankees Autographed Player-Worn White Jordan Shoes from the 2025 MLB Season — Judge Player-Worn White Jordan Shoes-line piece. Judge Player-Worn White Jordan Shoes at $3,000.
See It →Derek Jeter Premium Heirloom Pieces
Four picks — Jeter 16th Consecutive 150-Hit Inscription, Jeter Career RBI 1000 Inscription, Jeter HOF 2020 Bat, Jeter MN 1998 Authentic Jersey at $2,300-$3,300.
Derek Jeter New York Yankees Autographed 16th Consecutive 150-Hit Season Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 9/10 Ticket from September 14, 2011 with "16th 150 Hit Season" Inscription
Derek Jeter New York Yankees Autographed 16th Consecutive 150-Hit Season Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Inscription — Jeter 16th 150-Hit Inscription-line piece. Section top pick — Jeter 16th 150-Hit Inscription at $3,300.
See It →
Derek Jeter New York Yankees Autographed Gray Mitchell & Ness 1998 Authentic Jersey
Derek Jeter New York Yankees Autographed Gray Mitchell & Ness 1998 Authentic Jersey — Jeter MN 1998 Authentic Jersey-line piece. Jeter MN 1998 Authentic Jersey at $2,300.
See the Jersey →
Derek Jeter New York Yankees Autographed Game Model Black Bat with "HOF 2020" Inscription
Derek Jeter New York Yankees Autographed Game Model Black Bat with HOF 2020 Inscription — Jeter HOF 2020 Bat-line piece. Jeter HOF 2020 Bat at $2,400.
See It →
Derek Jeter New York Yankees Autographed Career RBI #1000 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Authenticated 7/10 Ticket from September 7, 2008 with "1000th Career RBI" Inscription
Derek Jeter New York Yankees Autographed Career RBI #1000 Beckett Fanatics Witnessed Inscription — Jeter Career RBI 1000-line piece. Jeter Career RBI 1000 at $3,000.
See It →Core Four Quad-Signed Memorabilia
Three Core Four (Jeter + Rivera + Posada + Pettitte) quad-signed picks at $2,500-$3,000 — generational dynasty pieces.
Derek Jeter, Andy Pettitte, Jorge Posada & Mariano Rivera New York Yankees Autographed Replica Batting Helmet - Signed in Blue Ink
Derek Jeter, Andy Pettitte, Jorge Posada & Mariano Rivera New York Yankees Autographed Replica Jersey — Core Four Quad Replica Jersey-line piece. Section top pick — Core Four Quad Replica Jersey at $3,000.
See the Sign →
Derek Jeter, Andy Pettitte, Jorge Posada & Mariano Rivera New York Yankees Autographed 1996 World Series Logo Baseball
Derek Jeter, Andy Pettitte, Jorge Posada & Mariano Rivera New York Yankees Autographed 1996 World Series Memorabilia — Core Four Quad 1996 WS-line piece. Core Four Quad 1996 WS at $2,500.
See It →
Andy Pettitte Derek Jeter Jorge Posada & Mariano Rivera New York Yankees Autographed Core Four Baseball
Andy Pettitte Derek Jeter Jorge Posada & Mariano Rivera New York Yankees Autographed Core Four Memorabilia — Core Four Quad Memorabilia-line piece. Core Four Quad Memorabilia at $2,500.
See It →Common questions
Frequently asked
How did we organize Yankees Heirloom Memorabilia?
Three sections: Aaron Judge premium heirloom pieces (Judge Embellished 30x40, Judge Player-Worn 2025 Jordan Shoes, Judge Fastest 70 HR Inscription, Judge 62nd HR Framed Collage), Derek Jeter premium heirloom pieces (Jeter 16th 150-Hit Inscription, Jeter Career RBI 1000 Inscription, Jeter HOF 2020 Bat, Jeter MN 1998 Authentic Jersey), and Core Four quad-signed memorabilia (Core Four Quad Replica Jersey, Core Four Quad 1996 WS, Core Four Quad Memorabilia). 11 picks from $2000 to $6000.
Best Yankees heirloom piece if I had to choose one?
For Judge marquee: the Aaron Judge Autographed 30x40 Embellished Photograph at $6,000 (section hero) — captain and 2x AL MVP autographed embellished. For Jeter marquee: the Derek Jeter Autographed 16th Consecutive 150-Hit Season Inscription at $3,300 (section 2 hero). For Core Four marquee: the Core Four Quad-Signed Replica Jersey at $3,000 (section 3 hero) — generational dynasty piece.
Aaron Judge Embellished 30x40 vs Player-Worn 2025 Jordan Shoes?
Two Aaron Judge premium heirloom picks. Aaron Judge 30x40 Embellished Photograph at $6,000 (section hero) features 30-by-40-inch stretched embellished photograph with Judge autograph. Aaron Judge Player-Worn White Jordan Brand Shoes from 2025 MLB Season at $3,000 features actual game-worn Jordan Brand shoes from the 2025 season with Judge autograph. For embellished art: 30x40 Embellished. For player-worn footwear: 2025 Jordan Shoes.
Aaron Judge Fastest 70 HR Inscription vs 62nd HR Framed Collage?
Two Aaron Judge career-milestone picks. Aaron Judge Fastest Player in MLB History to Reach 70 Home Runs Inscription at $2,500 features inscribed signature commemorating the fastest-to-70-HR mark. Aaron Judge 62nd Home Run Collage with Game-Used Dirt at $2,000 features 20-by-24-inch framed collage of the 62nd HR (the AL single-season HR record) with a capsule of game-used dirt. For 70 HR pace: Fastest 70 HR Inscription. For 62nd HR record: 62nd HR Framed Collage.
Derek Jeter 16th Consecutive 150-Hit Inscription vs Career RBI 1000 Inscription?
Two Derek Jeter career-milestone inscription picks. Derek Jeter 16th Consecutive 150-Hit Season Inscription at $3,300 (section 2 hero) features Beckett Fanatics witnessed authentication of Jeter's 16-consecutive-season 150-hit inscription — only player ever to do so. Derek Jeter Career RBI #1000 Inscription at $3,000 features Beckett Fanatics witnessed authentication of his 1000th career RBI. For 16-season hit streak: 16th 150-Hit. For RBI 1000: Career RBI 1000.
Derek Jeter HOF 2020 Bat vs MN 1998 Authentic Jersey?
Two Derek Jeter premium picks at $2,300-$2,400. Derek Jeter Game Model Black Bat with HOF 2020 Inscription at $2,400 features Game Model Black bat with the HOF 2020 inscription — Jeter was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 2020 (one vote shy of unanimous). Derek Jeter Gray Mitchell & Ness 1998 Authentic Jersey at $2,300 features Gray 1998 authentic Mitchell and Ness throwback Jersey from the 1998 World Series-championship season. For HOF 2020 Bat: HOF 2020 Bat. For 1998 WS Jersey: MN 1998 Authentic Jersey.
Core Four Quad Replica Jersey vs Core Four Quad 1996 WS Memorabilia?
Two Core Four (Jeter + Pettitte + Posada + Rivera) quad-signed picks. Core Four Quad-Signed Replica Jersey at $3,000 (section 3 hero) features all four Core Four signatures on a Yankees replica jersey. Core Four Quad-Signed 1996 World Series Memorabilia at $2,500 features quad-signed 1996 World Series memorabilia — the start of the dynasty that won 5 WS titles in 14 years. For replica jersey: Quad Replica Jersey. For 1996 WS heritage: Quad 1996 WS.
Didnt find the right Yankees heirloom piece? Browse the full Yankees collection on Fanatics for the complete catalog.
Shop the Full Yankees Collection →